Plea of necessity: Difference between revisions

From International cyber law: interactive toolkit
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Content added Content deleted
VisualWikitext
(added icon)
No edit summary
Line 8:
|[[File:Necessity.svg|alt=|left|frameless|200x200px]]The plea of necessity allows a State to act in exceptional cases when there is grave and imminent peril to an essential interest of the State and the action in question is the sole means of safeguarding that interest.<ref>ILC [http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/9_6_2001.pdf Articles on State Responsibility], Art 25(1)(a).</ref> Even then, the plea of necessity requires that the injured State’s action be balanced with the interests of any States that would be affected and with those of the international community.<ref>ILC [http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/9_6_2001.pdf Articles on State Responsibility], Art 25(1)(b).</ref> The injured State’s action must not seriously impair the essential interests of any other State.<ref>ILC [http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/9_6_2001.pdf Articles on State Responsibility], Art 25(1)(b).</ref> The plea of necessity is not available to injured States that have substantially contributed to the situation in which they find themselves.<ref>ILC [http://legal.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/commentaries/9_6_2001.pdf Articles on State Responsibility], Art 25(1)(b).</ref> However, the plea of necessity can be asserted to take action against non-State actors and can justify actions that violate the rights of non-responsible States, if these conditions are met. In case the situation of necessity is caused by the conduct of non-State actors, attribution of this conduct to a State is not a precondition for acting based on the plea of necessity.
|}<section end="Definition" />
 
==National positions==
===[[National position of France|France]]===
{{#lst:National position of France|FR necessity }}
===[[National position of Germany|Germany]]===
{{#lst:National position of Germany|DE necessity }}
===[[National position of Japan|Japan]]===
{{#lst:National position of Japan|JP necessity }}
===[[National position of Switzerland|Switzerland]]===
{{#lst:National position of Switzerland|CH necessity }}
===[[National position of the Netherlands|The Netherlands]]===
{{#lst:National position of the Netherlands|NL necessity }}
 
 
 
==Appendixes==

Revision as of 18:40, 1 August 2021

Definition

Plea of necessity
The plea of necessity allows a State to act in exceptional cases when there is grave and imminent peril to an essential interest of the State and the action in question is the sole means of safeguarding that interest.[1] Even then, the plea of necessity requires that the injured State’s action be balanced with the interests of any States that would be affected and with those of the international community.[2] The injured State’s action must not seriously impair the essential interests of any other State.[3] The plea of necessity is not available to injured States that have substantially contributed to the situation in which they find themselves.[4] However, the plea of necessity can be asserted to take action against non-State actors and can justify actions that violate the rights of non-responsible States, if these conditions are met. In case the situation of necessity is caused by the conduct of non-State actors, attribution of this conduct to a State is not a precondition for acting based on the plea of necessity.

National positions

France

Germany

Japan

Switzerland

The Netherlands

Appendixes

See also

Notes and references

  1. ↑ ILC Articles on State Responsibility, Art 25(1)(a).
  2. ↑ ILC Articles on State Responsibility, Art 25(1)(b).
  3. ↑ ILC Articles on State Responsibility, Art 25(1)(b).
  4. ↑ ILC Articles on State Responsibility, Art 25(1)(b).

Bibliography and further reading

Retrieved from "https://cyberlaw.ccdcoe.org/wiki/Plea_of_necessity?oldid=2524"